Molly Little and Angel Gostosa are decorating for a party and looking dapper for the new year. Nathan Bronson, Molly's stepbrother, can't resist staring at the females while they hang a banner and express their desire for cute boys since they both need a cute dick. Angel asks Nathan what he wants after noticing him watching.
When he admits to wanting a threesome, the females make fun of him. Molly promises Nathan he can have his way with them if he can remove both of their bras with a single hand before the countdown expires. Nathan enters his room to rehearse after accepting the assignment.
To the surprise of the females, Nathan pulls it off in the final two seconds. The girls jiggle their tiny titties as he then takes out a bubble blaster to start their celebration. Nathan then asks for a blowjob as his victory reward, and the girls obligingly comply.
They take the party to the couch after some intense ball sucking and deep throat face fucking. As the threesome gets started, Molly is on her knees getting a nice dick pounding from her stepbro while she eats Angel out. In order to give Angel some time in the middle, the girls switch places.
Molly gives up so Nathan, with Angel's assistance, can continue her New Year's Eve celebration. Angel takes her place next to Molly, mirroring her once more. An ideal way to start the new year, Nathan makes sure to get Angel off before pulling out to bust his nut on Angel's tummy.
Johnny and Lily Carter visit his sister, who wants to play cards. Johnny prefers shoot pool over Go Fish, while Lily prefers High Card No Pants. Johnny loses, loses trousers, and Lily's lips appear.
Riley Reid is nearing the completion of her associate's degree and is considering working as Professor Gunn's assistant to gain experience and extra credits. Despite the physical labor required, Riley is willing to take on the challenge, demonstrating her commitment to her studies.
Ana Foxxx finds Susan unconscious upstairs after a wild night with her lover, and is in need of help after breaking up with her unfaithful partner. Johnny comforts her and provides solace through his firm cock.
Lia Lor is unsure of her career goals and desires to travel before pursuing a profession. Professor Strong advises her to take time and find a solution. However, Lia Lor's decision to fuck her professor before graduation raises questions about her future.
Justin, a janitor, mocks Professor Longwood's liars in the psychology department. Tessa, a nervous student, expresses interest in psychology and agrees to volunteer for a study on sex and psychology. Tessa's naivety is highlighted as they learn from each other.
Christina seeks advice from her friend's brother to showcase her new dance moves, with Kris's guidance being based on an object pointing down his pants.
Amanda prepares for the night after spending the day with her kid and friends. Danny approaches her, revealing they are the only living there. Amanda initially hesitates but eventually shows Danny older ladies' worth.
Levi attends a family picnic with his friend Tara on his yacht, despite not attending. She surprises him by eating his cock instead of potato salad, and he's excited to join them.
Two college cheerleaders, Skin Diamond and Ana Foxxx, plan to seduce Judge Johnny to win a competition. However, they discover rival cheerleader Leilani Leeane is already licking his cock. Johnny must fuck each cheerleader to determine the winner.
Riley Evans is upset after accidentally crashing her boyfriend's car while texting, causing him to take it out. She asks his age-appropriate son, Johnny, to handle the fallout, but Johnny accepts and fucks his dad's girlfriend, causing her significant harm.